Discover how your personality type is secretly shaping your future.

You Should Be Happy, But You’re Not? Let’s Talk About Why—and What to Do About It

Share This:

Have you ever found yourself thinking, “I should be happy right now, but I’m just… not”? Maybe your life looks good on paper—career’s going well, relationships are steady, and you’re checking all the boxes—but deep down, something feels off. And then the guilt creeps in. You think, “Why do I feel this way when I have so much to be grateful for?”

If this sounds familiar, first of all, take a deep breath. You’re not alone. So many of us have been there, wondering why happiness seems just out of reach, even when everything appears to be going right. Let’s dive into why this happens—and, more importantly, what you can do about it.

Why You Might Not Feel Happy (Even When You Think You Should Be)

There’s a huge difference between how things look on the outside and how they feel on the inside. Just because life seems to be ticking all the boxes doesn’t mean it’s hitting all the right notes emotionally.

External vs. Internal Expectations

Sometimes, we build lives based on what we think we’re supposed to want. Society tells us that success means a stable job, a nice home, or achieving certain milestones. But if these external expectations don’t align with your internal values or passions, it’s no wonder you feel a disconnect. Just because something looks like success on the outside doesn’t mean it resonates with who you are at your core.

The Comparison Trap

It’s easy to fall into the comparison trap, especially with social media constantly in our faces. We see perfectly curated lives, vacations, achievements, and milestones, and suddenly we start questioning our own happiness. But remember, those are just highlight reels—they don’t show the full picture. Comparing your reality to someone else’s best moments will always leave you feeling like you’re falling short.

Lack of Alignment Between Your Values and Your Life

If you’re living a life that doesn’t align with what you truly value, it’s only natural to feel unfulfilled. You might have a great career, but if it doesn’t ignite your passion or align with what matters most to you—whether that’s creativity, freedom, family, or something else—it can leave you feeling empty, even if everything seems “perfect” on the outside.

The Pressure to Feel Happy—and Why It Backfires

Here’s the thing about happiness: the more you chase it, the more it seems to slip through your fingers. Telling yourself, “I should be happy,” can actually make you feel worse, because it adds layers of guilt and shame to the mix. You might think, “What’s wrong with me? Why can’t I just enjoy my life?”

But here’s the truth: happiness isn’t a constant state. It’s not something you feel 24/7. And that’s okay. The myth that we should always be happy is just that—a myth. Life has ups and downs, and expecting to feel blissed out all the time isn’t realistic or healthy.

How to Get to the Root of Your Unhappiness

So, if you’re feeling that disconnect between how life looks and how it feels, how do you start figuring out what’s really going on?

Reflect on What’s Really Important to You

Start by asking yourself some honest questions: What truly excites me? What brings me peace? What do I value most in life? It’s easy to get caught up in chasing goals that don’t actually matter to you, just because they seem like the “right” things to do. Take some time to reflect on what you genuinely want—not what you think you should want.

Evaluate How You Spend Your Time

Next, take a look at how you’re spending your days. Are your daily activities aligned with what you truly care about? Or are you just going through the motions? Sometimes, the simplest changes—like spending more time on things that bring you joy or cutting out activities that drain you—can make a huge difference in how fulfilled you feel.

Consider What’s Missing

Is there something you’ve been craving but haven’t made space for? Whether it’s meaningful relationships, creative expression, a sense of purpose, or time for yourself, consider what might be missing from your life. What’s the thing you’ve been pushing to the back burner, thinking you’ll get to it “someday”?

Practical Steps to Reclaim Happiness

Once you’ve reflected on what’s truly important to you, how do you start making changes to feel more aligned and fulfilled?

1. Align Your Life with Your Values

The first step is to align your life with your core values. This doesn’t mean you need to overhaul everything overnight. Start small. Maybe it’s setting boundaries at work so you have more time for family. Maybe it’s carving out time each week for a hobby you love. The key is to make intentional changes that bring you closer to the things that matter most to you.

2. Focus on Fulfillment, Not Just Success

Success is great, but it’s not the same as fulfillment. It’s easy to get caught up in the pursuit of external achievements, but true happiness comes from feeling fulfilled in what you do, not just ticking boxes. Ask yourself: What makes you feel fulfilled? Focus on that, even if it means redefining what success looks like for you.

3. Practice Gratitude and Acceptance

Gratitude is a powerful tool for shifting your perspective. But here’s the thing—practicing gratitude doesn’t mean ignoring the things that aren’t working in your life. It’s about finding balance: appreciating what you have while also acknowledging where you feel unfulfilled. It’s okay to feel both at the same time.

4. Seek Meaningful Connections

Sometimes what’s missing isn’t something external—it’s the depth of connection in your relationships. Take time to nurture the relationships that matter most to you, whether that’s with family, friends, or your partner. Meaningful connections can bring a sense of belonging and fulfillment that nothing else can.

Happiness Is About Alignment, Not Perfection

If there’s one thing to take away from this, it’s that true happiness isn’t about having a perfect life. It’s about living in alignment with your values, passions, and relationships. It’s about being honest with yourself about what matters most and making choices that reflect those truths.

So, what’s one small step you can take today to bring your life more in line with what truly matters to you? Maybe it’s spending time on a hobby you love, reconnecting with a friend, or simply reflecting on what’s important to you.

About the

AUTHOR

Picture of MARNI BATTISTA

MARNI BATTISTA

Marni Battista is an entrepreneur, author, transformational life design specialist, podcast host, and radical truth seeker who is on mission to help women harness the courage to stop letting life live them, and start LIVING a life that’s beyond their wildest dreams.

DISCOVER MORE From The

Radical Living

CHALLENGE

Be inspired. Click on the thumbnails below to view more radical living challenge stories

Our Last Week On The Oregon Coast — Part 2 — Finding Connection In The Unexpected Blessings

After the weekend at Cannon Beach we drove to a campsite near Portland in the town of Lake Oswego, a suburban bedroom community we ...
CONTINUE READING →

Are Weekends To Recover? Spending The Weekend At Mount Rainier To Figure It Out

Up until recently, I didn’t know that my weekends were mostly designed to recover. What that meant was that Jeremy and I would typically ...
CONTINUE READING →

Our Adventure Begins

…and so the adventure begins.
CONTINUE READING →

You’re the hero of your own story.

Decode

Your Destiny

Discover how your personality type is secretly shaping your future.
Scroll to Top